docs: record in-progress pre-prune verification evidence

2026-10-18 12:07:05 +09:00
parent 0635cec53d
commit ca5997fffa
2 changed files with 752 additions and 3 deletions
@@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ CLI는 입력 `.inp` 하나, lexical sibling HDF5·log, warning/오류 진단과

 ## 이번 병합의 현재 검증 상태

-직접 MSVC와 CMake/Ninja의 Debug solver/CLI 및 세 테스트 target build가 완료됐다.
+T2/T3 단계에서 직접 MSVC와 CMake/Ninja의 Debug solver/CLI 및 세 테스트 target build가 완료됐다.
 제품274개는 Refactor working bytes와 일치한다. 양쪽 실제 discovery는 unit849,
 integration72, reference43으로 총964개이며 canonical identity가 일치한다.
 최종 선별 실행은 CMake176개, Native15개, 합성 reference comparator28개,
@@ -72,6 +72,56 @@ Python145개가 failure/error/skip 없이 통과했다. 이는 전체964개 실
 2026-10-18 사용자 지시로 `reference/temp`는 검증에 사용하지 않는다. 정식 경로에 없는
 `shellNL-meshfine`, `shellNL-meshfine_02`, `shellNL-meshfine-pressure` 자료는 복사·복원하지 않는다.
 해당 실제 비교는 자료 미확보로 미완료이며 테스트를 skip 처리하거나 통과로 바꾸지 않는다.
-전체 Debug 검증·독립 수치 검토·정식 자료의 필수 비교는 후속 실행 대상이다.
+전체 Debug 검증·독립 수치 검토·정식 자료 비교의 현재 진행은 아래 T5 중간 기록과 구분한다.
 정리 전 필수 검증을 충족하지 못하면 테스트 삭제와 최종 병합 완료 판정을 진행하지 않는다.
-문서 갱신 자체로 build/test를 추가 실행하지 않았다.
+T4 문서 갱신 자체로 build/test를 추가 실행하지 않았다.
+
+### T5 정리 전 검증 중간 기록 — 전체 완료 아님
+
+2026-10-18에 전체 Native Debug 솔루션, CMake Debug configure/build와 Ninja dependency
+검사를 새로 실행해 모두 exit0을 확인했다. 제품102 compile unit의 dependency가 유효하고,
+양쪽 세 테스트 executable의 실제 identity는 unit849·integration72·reference43,
+CTest964개로 일치한다. Public header111개는 각각 독립 TU로 private/vendor include 경로 없이
+MSVC C++17 `/EHsc /W4 /WX /MDd /Zs` 검사를 통과했다. CLI·test의 네 runtime 디렉터리에서
+DLL7개의 SHA256이 같다. 제품274개와 정식 reference32개 bytes도 중간 기록 전에 재확인했다.
+`reference/temp`의12개 경로는 byte 검증 대상에서 제외했고 입력·CSV·결과를 사용하지 않았다.
+
+Native unit 전체는 필터 없이 계속 실행 중이며 **전체 종료 코드와 XML은 아직 없다**.
+중간 stdout에서 완료57개 identity를 관측했으며 다음 개별 검사는 새로 PASS 종료했다.
+
+- `ReducedManufacturedControllerKeepsExactInitialOrbit`: 396862ms.
+- `C08aRigidManufacturedOrbitReducedCoordinateTimeConvergence`: 7-grid, 7153515ms.
+- `C08bInitialPhysicalSpectrumProbe`: 716ms.
+- `PredictorStartCompletesPreviouslyFailingLumpedFreePlateGrid`: 539678ms.
+
+현재 `C08bFreeFiniteRotationPlateSelfConvergenceAndPhysicalInvariants`의8-grid를 수행한다.
+h=1/64·1/128·1/256·1/512·1/1024의 계산 요약이 생성됐으나 남은8192·16384·32768증분
+fine-grid와 최종 시간수렴·물리 gate는 미완료다. 모든 grid의 총 증분수는57840이다.
+CPU/RSS 상승이나 부분 로그를 전체 통과 근거로 삼지 않는다. Native 나머지 executable,
+전체 CTest와 Python suite는 같은 직렬 큐에서 대기하며 임의 timeout·skip·필터를 추가하지 않았다.
+
+Refactor 원본 밖 별도 source snapshot304개에서 Native Debug 기준 solver/CLI를 새로
+빌드해 exit0과 DLL7개 일치를 확인했다. 정적5모델을 포함한 정식 입력11개에 대해 기준·Native·
+CMake 실행물을 같은 scratch 입력 경로와 bytes에서 직렬 실행하고 schema·identity·각 field를
+대조하는 후속 큐를 준비했다. **새 실제 모델 실행·비교는 아직 시작하지 않았다.** 보고서 JSON의
+case·policy·quantity와 실제 exit를 확인하며, parity의 빈 결과·자료 부재·dtype 차이·불일치는
+nonzero로 남긴다. Exact field assertion의 불일치를 새 물리 허용치 위반으로 승격하지 않고
+출처·dtype·identity·rounding 차이를 분류한 뒤 기존 승인 기준과 대조한다. 임시 도구의 합성
+증거 하한 검사9건은 솔버나 물리 검증 통과가 아니다. 빈 결과·자료 누락의 옛 false-green을
+각각 exit0으로 재현하고 수정 후 exit1·exit2가 되는 것을 확인했다.
+
+독립 수치 검토는 명백한 식 오류나 승인 기준 변경을 발견하지 못했으나 `CONCERNS`다.
+inverse→factor solve·Jet·eigen whitening·paired 산술과 spatial RM 변환은 rounding graph에
+영향이 있어 비트 보존을 가정하지 않는다. 특히 `hdf5_primitives.cpp`, dynamic/nonlinear HDF5
+writer의 `J^T m=g` LU action은 T2 영향 routing 누락을 T5 manifest에 보충하고 finite-rotation
+virtual-work·완전 inverse action·HDF5 reaction readback 검사 identity에 연결했다.
+이 정적 검토를 실제 전체 실행·reference closure의 승인으로 해석하지 않는다.
+
+정식 `shellNL-meshfine`·`shellNL-meshfine-pressure`는 자료 미확보로 미실행이고,
+`shellNL-meshfine_02`는 자료 부재와 현재 comparator 연결 부재를 함께 남긴다.
+Thermal 새 필수 reference 부재와 기존 NT11 diagnostic/nonblocking 불일치도 유지한다.
+필수 gate를 충족하지 않았으므로 테스트 삭제·T6 진입·최종 병합 완료 판정을 진행하지 않는다.
+
+중간 근거는 `.build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/`에 있으며
+`running-checkpoint.json`과 `progress.jsonl`이 실행 큐·PID·현재 관측을 보존한다.
+파일 manifest의 `t5_before_prune_verification`은 이 중간 snapshot을 기록하며 T1/T2/T3 원필드는 보존했다.
@@ -32644,5 +32644,704 @@
    "removed_tests": [],
    "policy_failure_reproduction": "native ExceptionHandling을 메모리에서 false로 바꾸면 현재 policy 검사가 AssertionError로 거부하고 원문 설정에서는 통과한다. 파일은 수정하지 않는다.",
    "policy_failure_evidence": ".build/merge-verification/t3-20261018-01/policy-mutation.log"
+  },
+  "t5_before_prune_verification": {
+    "status": "IN_PROGRESS_NOT_A_T5_COMPLETION_OR_T6_GATE",
+    "snapshot_utc": "2026-10-18T02:59:51.000255+00:00",
+    "base_commit": "0635cec53d9d617503d4ae9b57a97c82b8f9f9b9",
+    "scope": "정리 전 전체 검증의 중간 근거. 제품·검사·등록·정식 reference 수정이나 테스트 삭제 없음. 미생성 exit/XML을 통과로 계산하지 않는다.",
+    "raw_evidence": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune",
+    "user_decision": "reference/temp는 검증에 사용하지 않는다. 임시 입력/CSV/결과를 읽어 검증·비교·복사하거나 정식 자료로 대체하지 않았다.",
+    "completed_build_checks": {
+      "native-build": {
+        "record": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/native-build.json",
+        "log": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/native-build.log",
+        "argv": [
+          "MSBuild",
+          "FESA.sln",
+          "/m:2",
+          "/p:Configuration=Debug",
+          "/p:Platform=x64"
+        ],
+        "actual_argv": [
+          "cmd",
+          "/d",
+          "/c",
+          "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\native-build.cmd"
+        ],
+        "cwd": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker",
+        "exit": 0,
+        "seconds": 2.6927127838134766,
+        "removed_filter_variables": {},
+        "environment": {
+          "TMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\native-build-tmp",
+          "TEMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\native-build-tmp",
+          "PYTHONUTF8": "1",
+          "PYTHONIOENCODING": "utf-8"
+        },
+        "log_sha256": "e49b0b496b2e4a0c6e6fa8aa1e108e405a75647df0ecb0ef08044bd178f8b422"
+      },
+      "configure": {
+        "record": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/configure.json",
+        "log": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/configure.log",
+        "argv": [
+          "cmake",
+          "--preset",
+          "windows-msvc-ninja-debug"
+        ],
+        "actual_argv": [
+          "cmd",
+          "/d",
+          "/c",
+          "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\configure.cmd"
+        ],
+        "cwd": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker",
+        "exit": 0,
+        "seconds": 1.9974191188812256,
+        "removed_filter_variables": {},
+        "environment": {
+          "TMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\configure-tmp",
+          "TEMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\configure-tmp",
+          "PYTHONUTF8": "1",
+          "PYTHONIOENCODING": "utf-8"
+        },
+        "log_sha256": "6723be76fc9b32cb2579c441582eadd6a31d0f42bebdf7d33a274235f1f3305c"
+      },
+      "cmake-build": {
+        "record": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/cmake-build.json",
+        "log": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/cmake-build.log",
+        "argv": [
+          "cmake",
+          "--build",
+          "--preset",
+          "windows-msvc-ninja-debug",
+          "--parallel",
+          "2"
+        ],
+        "actual_argv": [
+          "cmd",
+          "/d",
+          "/c",
+          "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\cmake-build.cmd"
+        ],
+        "cwd": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker",
+        "exit": 0,
+        "seconds": 3.918487310409546,
+        "removed_filter_variables": {},
+        "environment": {
+          "TMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\cmake-build-tmp",
+          "TEMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\cmake-build-tmp",
+          "PYTHONUTF8": "1",
+          "PYTHONIOENCODING": "utf-8"
+        },
+        "log_sha256": "db6dcbe64f97503b1513ba88244422e134ec6a15385f58b854eda665b462b76f"
+      },
+      "ninja-deps": {
+        "record": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/ninja-deps.json",
+        "log": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/ninja-deps.log",
+        "argv": [
+          "ninja",
+          "-C",
+          ".build/cmake-debug",
+          "-t",
+          "deps"
+        ],
+        "actual_argv": [
+          "cmd",
+          "/d",
+          "/c",
+          "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\ninja-deps.cmd"
+        ],
+        "cwd": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker",
+        "exit": 0,
+        "seconds": 1.740182876586914,
+        "removed_filter_variables": {},
+        "environment": {
+          "TMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\ninja-deps-tmp",
+          "TEMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\ninja-deps-tmp",
+          "PYTHONUTF8": "1",
+          "PYTHONIOENCODING": "utf-8"
+        },
+        "log_sha256": "98e36f6181baa49c61172dcf61a757ef89295bdb8383037071599da5022780db"
+      },
+      "headers-compile": {
+        "record": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/headers-compile.json",
+        "log": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/headers-compile.log",
+        "argv": [
+          "cl",
+          "@C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\headers\\compile.rsp"
+        ],
+        "actual_argv": [
+          "cmd",
+          "/d",
+          "/c",
+          "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\headers-compile.cmd"
+        ],
+        "cwd": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker",
+        "exit": 0,
+        "seconds": 201.70288968086243,
+        "removed_filter_variables": {},
+        "environment": {
+          "TMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\headers-compile-tmp",
+          "TEMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\headers-compile-tmp",
+          "PYTHONUTF8": "1",
+          "PYTHONIOENCODING": "utf-8"
+        },
+        "log_sha256": "99ec0b9178d41ec674584c6e2f94d8f414daf81af3e3b57f83d876f81ec8bf83"
+      },
+      "baseline-build": {
+        "record": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/baseline-build.json",
+        "log": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/baseline-build.log",
+        "argv": [
+          "MSBuild",
+          "msvc/fesa_cli.vcxproj",
+          "/m:2",
+          "/p:Configuration=Debug",
+          "/p:Platform=x64"
+        ],
+        "actual_argv": [
+          "cmd",
+          "/d",
+          "/c",
+          "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\baseline-build.cmd"
+        ],
+        "cwd": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\t5-refactor-baseline",
+        "exit": 0,
+        "seconds": 161.69524788856506,
+        "removed_filter_variables": {},
+        "environment": {
+          "TMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\baseline-build-tmp",
+          "TEMP": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\baseline-build-tmp",
+          "PYTHONUTF8": "1",
+          "PYTHONIOENCODING": "utf-8"
+        },
+        "log_sha256": "1c763c2aee61f9f1975912373576f420322a892f260ec23c05dc495294d1b6c2"
+      }
+    },
+    "source_fidelity": {
+      "product_files": 274,
+      "refactor_working_bytes_equal": true,
+      "rechecked_before_interim_record": true,
+      "hash_evidence": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/pre-execution-hashes.json",
+      "canonical_reference_files_checked": 32,
+      "canonical_reference_bytes_unchanged": true,
+      "temp_paths_excluded_before_byte_reads": 12
+    },
+    "discovery": {
+      "native_unit": 849,
+      "native_integration": 72,
+      "native_reference": 43,
+      "cmake_unit": 849,
+      "cmake_integration": 72,
+      "cmake_reference": 43,
+      "ctest": 964,
+      "canonical_identity_match": true,
+      "evidence": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/discovery-summary.json"
+    },
+    "public_header_check": {
+      "independent_translation_units": 111,
+      "mode": "MSVC C++17 /EHsc /W4 /WX /MDd /Zs; include/ and VS/Windows standard INCLUDE only, no private/vendor include path",
+      "exit": 0,
+      "translation_unit_map": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/headers-map.json",
+      "environment": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/headers-environment.log"
+    },
+    "dependency_check": {
+      "all_object_entries": 222,
+      "production_object_entries": 102,
+      "invalid_production_entries": []
+    },
+    "runtime_dlls": {
+      "count": 7,
+      "native_cli_native_tests_cmake_cli_cmake_tests_sha256_equal": true,
+      "fresh_refactor_baseline_equal": true,
+      "evidence": [
+        ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/all-target-runtime-dll-parity.json",
+        ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/baseline-runtime.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    "full_suite_execution": {
+      "status": "RUNNING_NATIVE_UNIT_NO_SUITE_EXIT_OR_XML_YET",
+      "serial_queue": [
+        "Native unit849 unfiltered",
+        "Native integration72 unfiltered",
+        "Native reference43 unfiltered",
+        "CTest964 unfiltered -j1",
+        "Python entire tests/ suite"
+      ],
+      "per_run_TMP_TEMP_and_raw_separated": true,
+      "inherited_GTEST_CTEST_variables_removed": true,
+      "pre_existing_fixed_reference_outputs_preserved": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/pre-existing",
+      "explicit_ctest_timeout_properties": 0,
+      "timeout_evidence": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/ctest-timeout-static.json",
+      "native_completed_identity_count_in_stdout": 57,
+      "native_completed_identities_in_stdout": [
+        {
+          "identity": "BuildInfo.VersionIsStableAndNonEmpty",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "BuildInfo.PublicHeaderHasNoBackendDependency",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "Analysis.PropagatesStatusAndDestroysThroughMinimalAnalysis",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisProcedure.PreparedConsumerPreservesDomainFailureAndLifetime",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EquilibriumAlgorithm.RetainsMoveOnlyCandidateUntilProcedureTakesIt",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EquilibriumAlgorithm.FirstFailedEvaluationLeavesNoAcceptedCandidate",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EquilibriumAlgorithm.InjectsAlternativeOrderAndPreservesTypedPendingOnFailure",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "ProcedureIntegratorInjection.ShellValuesUseProductionStepAndPreserveHistory",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "ProcedureIntegratorInjection.SolidPairedValuesUseProductionStepAndPreserveHistory",
+          "milliseconds": 2
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "ProcedureIntegratorInjection.HeatValuesUseProductionRecoveryCommitAndPreserveHistory",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisModel.ClassifiesActiveEntitiesInStableOrder",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisModel.ReferencesWithoutCopyingOrMutatingDomain",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisModel.KeepsNonOwningMixedDefinitionAndPropertyIndices",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisModel.RejectsMissingOrMultipleStep",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisState.AllocatesOnlyV0FullVectors",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisState.CopiesOrMovesWithoutAliasing",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisState.PreservesStepFrameAndStableRowOrder",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisState.OwnsExactShellRowsInStableElementAndLocationOrder",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisState.CommitsFiniteShellGlobalEvidence",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "AnalysisState.InvalidShellCandidatesLeavePriorStateUnchanged",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "DynamicAnalysisState.RejectsUnknownOrChangingIntegrationFormulation",
+          "milliseconds": 5
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "DynamicAnalysisState.DefaultStateRejectsTrialAndCommit",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "DynamicAnalysisState.CommitsCompleteZeroCorrectionHistoryAndCopiesTrials",
+          "milliseconds": 1
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "DynamicAnalysisState.RejectsMalformedInventoryScheduleAndPreservesEndpoint",
+          "milliseconds": 4
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "DynamicAnalysisState.RejectsInvalidInitialStateAndFreeReaction",
+          "milliseconds": 1
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "DynamicAnalysisState.CreateRejectsInvalidScheduleAndNonzeroBoundary",
+          "milliseconds": 3
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.RejectsNonfiniteUsedBasisAndPreservesPriorCandidate",
+          "milliseconds": 4
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.KeepsPositivePartialGlobalRotationAndOriginalPencil",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.RemovesOnlyActualFreeDirectorNull",
+          "milliseconds": 1
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.RejectsPositiveButUnresolvableMassWithoutDeletingDofs",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.WhitensOffDiagonalMassAndRestoresOriginalPencil",
+          "milliseconds": 135
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.PreservesSmallResolvablePositivePartialRotationMass",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.HandlesTwoFreeRotationsAndRejectsEmptyFiniteSpace",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.PureMassWhiteningRetainsInclusiveInfinityConditionGate",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenReduction.PureOffDiagonalWhiteningMatchesAnalyticGramAndPencil",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "EigenMassAssembly.ScattersHeterogeneousSharedNodeMassInSourceOrder",
+          "milliseconds": 88
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtTimeIntegrationTest.KeepsPhysicalAndAlgorithmicAccelerationDistinct",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtTimeIntegrationTest.RejectsInvalidParametersAndTime",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtTimeIntegrationTest.StepOscillatorHasSecondOrderMaximumError",
+          "milliseconds": 6
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.NodalRigidForceRatesMatchIndependentTimeDifferences",
+          "milliseconds": 73
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.ExternalDrillingHessianBalancesGradientAcceleration",
+          "milliseconds": 40
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.ManufacturedHiddenCountsExternalHessianOnce",
+          "milliseconds": 153
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.C08aRigidOrbitMatchesIndependentVolumeForcePowerAndMomentum",
+          "milliseconds": 2462
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.BasisCoefficientRadiusSurvivesSparseProjectionAndLift",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.BasisRadiusReplayMatchesCompensatedProjectionAndCombinedLift",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.BasisLiftedAlgorithmicCorrectionUsesHhtFilterFactor",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.CarriedArRadiiIncludeAbsorbedUpdatesAndInputHistory",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.PrimaryCoordinateRetainsCorrectionAbsorbedByCarriedAr",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.CompensatedCoordinateRetainsAbsorbedNewtonCorrections",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.FrozenGraphIndicatorIncludesCoordinateAndRateCurvature",
+          "milliseconds": 3
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.GraphBasisCertificateBoundsMatrixAndRhsPerturbations",
+          "milliseconds": 2
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.RestrictedLastSolvePreservesOmittedTranslationDefect",
+          "milliseconds": 0
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.RestrictedRecordNoiseIncludesFullModelOmittedUDefect",
+          "milliseconds": 316
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.ReducedManufacturedControllerKeepsExactInitialOrbit",
+          "milliseconds": 396862
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.C08aRigidManufacturedOrbitReducedCoordinateTimeConvergence",
+          "milliseconds": 7153515
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.C08bInitialPhysicalSpectrumProbe",
+          "milliseconds": 716
+        },
+        {
+          "identity": "HhtShellPhysics.PredictorStartCompletesPreviouslyFailingLumpedFreePlateGrid",
+          "milliseconds": 539678
+        }
+      ],
+      "native_failed_identity_lines_so_far": [],
+      "native_skipped_identity_lines_so_far": [],
+      "native_current_identity": "HhtShellPhysics.C08bFreeFiniteRotationPlateSelfConvergenceAndPhysicalInvariants",
+      "native_c08b_completed_time_grids": [
+        {
+          "h": "1/64",
+          "increments": 16
+        },
+        {
+          "h": "1/128",
+          "increments": 32
+        },
+        {
+          "h": "1/256",
+          "increments": 64
+        },
+        {
+          "h": "1/512",
+          "increments": 128
+        },
+        {
+          "h": "1/1024",
+          "increments": 256
+        }
+      ],
+      "c08b_remaining_fine_grid_increments": [
+        8192,
+        16384,
+        32768
+      ],
+      "c08b_total_increments_all_grids": 57840,
+      "c08b_final_convergence_and_physics_status": "NOT_COMPLETE",
+      "warning": "stdout 관측은 전체 XML/exit를 대신하지 않는다. CPU/RSS/로그 크기를 수치 진척이나 통과의 근거로 쓰지 않는다.",
+      "running_checkpoint": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/running-checkpoint.json",
+      "native_stdout": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/native-fesa_unit_tests.log",
+      "queued_suites_and_python": "NOT_RUN_YET"
+    },
+    "fresh_refactor_baseline": {
+      "source_root": "C:/git/FESADev/.dryforge/t5-refactor-baseline",
+      "source_pin": "11f09eeb9460115758eada96deda1d0b08c4a442",
+      "tracked_selected_files_copied": 304,
+      "copied_roots": [
+        "include",
+        "src",
+        "msvc",
+        "FESA.sln"
+      ],
+      "excluded": [
+        ".build",
+        "reference/temp",
+        "original retained outputs"
+      ],
+      "source_snapshot": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/baseline-source-snapshot.json",
+      "build": "Native MSVC x64 Debug solver/CLI fresh build exit0",
+      "fresh_model_execution": "NOT_RUN_YET; starts after all suites including Python exit",
+      "model_queue": "11 available canonical inputs x Refactor baseline/Native/CMake; minimum static5 plus affected frequency/HHT/thermal models; serial, no arbitrary wall timeout",
+      "pipeline_scripts": [
+        ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/after-suites.py",
+        ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/models.py",
+        ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/hdf-parity.py",
+        ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/reference-harness.cpp"
+      ],
+      "parity_policy": "동일 scratch input 경로·bytes에서 새로 실행한 schema·identity·각 field 값과 실제 차이를 대조한다. 출처 동일성을 수치/물리 동등성으로 주장하지 않는다."
+    },
+    "independent_numerical_review": {
+      "status": "CONCERNS_STATIC_REVIEW_ONLY",
+      "report": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/numerical-review-ko.md",
+      "sha256": "3a181a24665e778a19111e8d5e145c01547300dd4f2651f81b6cbfee31d884cd",
+      "conclusion": "검토한 원문과 소스에서 명백한 식 오류·승인 기준 변경은 발견하지 못했으나 rounding graph·수명 영향과 실제 검증 의무는 남는다. 이 의견은 full T5 PASS 또는 T6 승인 근거가 아니다."
+    },
+    "supplemental_numerical_impact_classification": [
+      {
+        "path": "src/fesa/io/hdf5/hdf5_primitives.cpp",
+        "category": "spatial reaction output arithmetic: analytic inverse-transpose multiply -> LU solve J^T m=g",
+        "contract": "virtual-work spatial moment 변환식은 같으나 rounding graph가 달라 비트 보존을 가정하지 않는다. schema·identity·수치 허용치 변경 없음.",
+        "reason": "T2 numerical routing 누락을 독립 수치 검토가 발견했다. T1/T2 원본 필드를 수정하지 않고 T5에 보충한다.",
+        "required_oracle_identities": [
+          "FiniteRotation.SpatialMomentSolvePreservesKnownLoadAndVirtualWork",
+          "FiniteRotation.JacobiansAreFiniteInverseTransposeAndDerivativeConsistent",
+          "DynamicHdf5ResultsWriter.ConvertsPartialConstraintMomentToSpatialReaction",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.ProjectsRotationalReactionToSpatialMoment",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.WritesSchemaV1ModelAndCommittedAcceptedFramesOnly",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.CandidateFinalizationFailurePreservesPriorFinal"
+        ],
+        "current_full_execution_status": "PENDING; discovered but not reached in current Native full unit; CTest not started yet"
+      },
+      {
+        "path": "src/fesa/io/hdf5/dynamic_hdf5_results_writer.cpp",
+        "category": "spatial reaction output arithmetic: analytic inverse-transpose multiply -> LU solve J^T m=g",
+        "contract": "virtual-work spatial moment 변환식은 같으나 rounding graph가 달라 비트 보존을 가정하지 않는다. schema·identity·수치 허용치 변경 없음.",
+        "reason": "T2 numerical routing 누락을 독립 수치 검토가 발견했다. T1/T2 원본 필드를 수정하지 않고 T5에 보충한다.",
+        "required_oracle_identities": [
+          "FiniteRotation.SpatialMomentSolvePreservesKnownLoadAndVirtualWork",
+          "FiniteRotation.JacobiansAreFiniteInverseTransposeAndDerivativeConsistent",
+          "DynamicHdf5ResultsWriter.ConvertsPartialConstraintMomentToSpatialReaction",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.ProjectsRotationalReactionToSpatialMoment",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.WritesSchemaV1ModelAndCommittedAcceptedFramesOnly",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.CandidateFinalizationFailurePreservesPriorFinal"
+        ],
+        "current_full_execution_status": "PENDING; discovered but not reached in current Native full unit; CTest not started yet"
+      },
+      {
+        "path": "src/fesa/io/hdf5/nonlinear_hdf5_results_writer.cpp",
+        "category": "spatial reaction output arithmetic: analytic inverse-transpose multiply -> LU solve J^T m=g",
+        "contract": "virtual-work spatial moment 변환식은 같으나 rounding graph가 달라 비트 보존을 가정하지 않는다. schema·identity·수치 허용치 변경 없음.",
+        "reason": "T2 numerical routing 누락을 독립 수치 검토가 발견했다. T1/T2 원본 필드를 수정하지 않고 T5에 보충한다.",
+        "required_oracle_identities": [
+          "FiniteRotation.SpatialMomentSolvePreservesKnownLoadAndVirtualWork",
+          "FiniteRotation.JacobiansAreFiniteInverseTransposeAndDerivativeConsistent",
+          "DynamicHdf5ResultsWriter.ConvertsPartialConstraintMomentToSpatialReaction",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.ProjectsRotationalReactionToSpatialMoment",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.WritesSchemaV1ModelAndCommittedAcceptedFramesOnly",
+          "NonlinearHdf5ResultsWriter.CandidateFinalizationFailurePreservesPriorFinal"
+        ],
+        "current_full_execution_status": "PENDING; discovered but not reached in current Native full unit; CTest not started yet"
+      }
+    ],
+    "unresolved_reference_checks": [
+      {
+        "case": "shellNL-meshfine",
+        "status": "NOT_RUN_MISSING_CANONICAL_MATERIAL",
+        "reason": "정식 입력/CSV 미확보; temp는 사용하지 않는다."
+      },
+      {
+        "case": "shellNL-meshfine_02",
+        "status": "NOT_RUN_MISSING_CANONICAL_MATERIAL_AND_CURRENT_COMPARATOR_CONNECTION",
+        "reason": "정식 자료도 없고 현재 ContractFor 연결도 없는 별도 후속 범위다."
+      },
+      {
+        "case": "shellNL-meshfine-pressure",
+        "status": "NOT_RUN_MISSING_CANONICAL_MATERIAL",
+        "reason": "정식 입력/CSV 미확보; temp는 사용하지 않는다."
+      },
+      {
+        "case": "thermal-new-required-reference",
+        "status": "NOT_RUN_NOT_SUPPLIED",
+        "reason": "새 필수 모델/NT11 CSV 미확보. 기존 NT11 비교는 diagnostic/nonblocking 불일치로 유지하며 새 필수자료 통과로 대체하지 않는다."
+      }
+    ],
+    "preserved_limits": [
+      "ShellNL RF/RM review-only, stress Gauss/CSV mapping 미판정",
+      "기존 thermal NT11 diagnostic 불일치를 외부 PASS로 승격하지 않음",
+      "HHT C08a 현재 개별 PASS와 C08b·전체 회귀·전체 물리 closure 구분",
+      "eigen S3 partial-BC 정적 충돌·성능 미완료 유지"
+    ],
+    "helper_attempts": ".build/merge-verification/t5-20261018-01/before-prune/helper-preparation-attempts.json",
+    "test_pruning": {
+      "removed_tests": [],
+      "status": "BLOCKED_BEHIND_REQUIRED_T5_CHECKS",
+      "reason": "필수 실제 비교와 전체 실행 gate가 충족되지 않았다."
+    },
+    "temporary_evidence_floor": {
+      "status": "synthetic tooling checks only; no FESA model execution",
+      "checked_cases": {
+        "scope": "임시 검증도구의 증거 하한 검사만 수행. FESA solver·물리·reference 검증이 아니다.",
+        "checks": [
+          {
+            "synthetic_tooling_case": "empty",
+            "exit": 1,
+            "expected": 1,
+            "report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-empty\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_tooling_case": "attribute-dtype-mismatch",
+            "exit": 1,
+            "expected": 1,
+            "report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-attribute-dtype-mismatch\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_tooling_case": "missing-result",
+            "exit": 2,
+            "expected": 2,
+            "report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-missing-result\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_tooling_case": "nonempty-identical",
+            "exit": 0,
+            "expected": 0,
+            "report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-nonempty-identical\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_tooling_case": "comparator exit0 with malformed JSON",
+            "exit": 2,
+            "expected": 2
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "validators": [
+        ".build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\hdf-parity.py",
+        ".build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\validate-report.py"
+      ],
+      "aggregate": "Every solver/comparator/validator/parity exit is preserved; any nonzero yields nonzero aggregate. Known thermal diagnostic numeric FAIL remains separately classified, never numeric PASS.",
+      "tool_source_sha256": {
+        "models.py": "d59893216881fea11d48f28fc38e4d0c195815ea1c688ce5b20c308dd5708ce9",
+        "hdf-parity.py": "a277726e72fd335d0e1e5af8fc4df46a62e71d45d57d91d3ee21e859d56cb9f8",
+        "validate-report.py": "80a9729285969b81a4e2f2f7773a3f3588ddaff59586f1902c61e84c94796abc",
+        "reference-harness.cpp": "dac5dbf6ad084420e94439224191ca328f1ef01a4fc9892512bc06e1782fac11"
+      },
+      "false_green_regression_checks": {
+        "scope": "임시 도구의 false-green 재현/수정 확인만 수행. FESA 제품·물리·실제 reference 통과가 아니다.",
+        "checks": [
+          {
+            "synthetic_case": "legacy-empty",
+            "before_exit": 0,
+            "after_exit": 1,
+            "expected_after_exit": 1,
+            "before_report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-legacy-empty\\legacy-false-green-parity.json",
+            "after_report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-legacy-empty\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_case": "legacy-missing",
+            "before_exit": 0,
+            "after_exit": 2,
+            "expected_after_exit": 2,
+            "before_report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-legacy-missing\\legacy-false-green-parity.json",
+            "after_report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-legacy-missing\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_case": "numeric-mismatch",
+            "before_exit": null,
+            "after_exit": 1,
+            "expected_after_exit": 1,
+            "before_report": null,
+            "after_report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-numeric-mismatch\\parity.json"
+          },
+          {
+            "synthetic_case": "nonfinite",
+            "before_exit": null,
+            "after_exit": 1,
+            "expected_after_exit": 1,
+            "before_report": null,
+            "after_report": "C:\\git\\FESADev\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\worker\\.build\\merge-verification\\t5-20261018-01\\before-prune\\models\\tooling-floor-nonfinite\\parity.json"
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "synthetic_case_count": 9,
+      "parity_disposition": "Exact-field nonzero is a comparison assertion result, not a new physical acceptance tolerance. Differences require source/dtype/identity/rounding cause classification against existing approved policies; no tolerance added or relaxed.",
+      "aggregate_validation_status": "Static implementation reviewed; actual full model aggregate has not run yet."
+    }
  }
 }