{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "reviewer": "model_conformance independent spec reviewer",
  "base": "58410281e015c6600dc543c4e093fd95c036288c",
  "reviewDateUtc": "2026-10-07T17:03:27.724783+00:00",
  "status": "pass",
  "blockers": [],
  "readOnlyScope": "Repository and worktrees read-only; Python bytes/SHA/FBX parsing and image viewing only; no Blender/Unity/commit/runtime adoption. Writes limited to .dryforge/reviews evidence.",
  "userApproval": "PENDING; this review does not approve runtime adoption",
  "runtimeVerification": "NOT_RUN; later approved Unity integration must verify actual interaction, selection, 30-stage mapping and Android",
  "task": "T1",
  "branch": "dryforge/hero-model",
  "commit": "7d7efbe6b6a1a419ac998f37e3e019a75570a9e5",
  "worktree": "C:\\git\\MagnetismHeroes\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\T1",
  "changedFiles": 7,
  "evidenceRoot": "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes",
  "artifacts": [
    {
      "path": "SourceAssets/Models/Heroes/MagneticKnight.blend",
      "bytes": 1833499,
      "sha256": "7ce1272dfe861aee986609cdb899f0edf8b8f2f0f17269c0eda472c8aa90ee3a"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Heroes/HeroBody.fbx",
      "bytes": 60076,
      "sha256": "56f3301176c612ebeab3fdaaba5c019674beeb0f727f97ed27dd67e32ff50a40"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Heroes/KnightEquipment.fbx",
      "bytes": 222764,
      "sha256": "a8059a020e79e080635e7326bb91576010cad10c60ee931d95536d47fe76e61c"
    }
  ],
  "hashes": "Source/2 FBX/face atlas/six sprite records independently matched actual bytes",
  "preservation": "13 original FBX byte-identical; existing provenance Git blobs unchanged; only 7 added candidate/tool/doc files; no manual meta or runtime wiring",
  "findings": [
    {
      "spec": "Body mesh/material improvement, radius .5m and root scale1",
      "evidence": [
        "tools/models/build_hero.py:238",
        "tools/models/build_hero.py:251",
        "SourceAssets/Models/Heroes/verification.json",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/body_standalone.png"
      ],
      "observed": "New smooth body mesh/material authored. Actual FBX 1986 vertices with radii .499999984 to .500000019m; 1 body mesh and 22 equipment meshes, default scale1 and shared origin."
    },
    {
      "spec": "Rounded open helmet, short blunt sword, round shield; existing 6 expressions, thin blue mask and cape coexist",
      "evidence": [
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/hero_three_quarter.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/knight_front.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/knight_side.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/knight_back.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/expression_0_Neutral.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/expression_5_Celebrating.png"
      ],
      "observed": "All 11 actual PNGs viewed. No face/eye/mouth occlusion or visible broken silhouette preventing the later interaction promise. Intentional attachment overlap is not treated as a solid-intersection-zero requirement."
    },
    {
      "spec": "Editable source, export/reopen/mesh/SHA checks, source-to-game-file provenance; preview-only atlas reuse",
      "evidence": [
        "SourceAssets/Models/Heroes/README.md",
        "SourceAssets/Models/Heroes/provenance.json",
        "SourceAssets/Models/Heroes/verification.json",
        "tools/models/build_hero.py:138",
        "tools/models/build_hero.py:212",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/build-final.log",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Heroes/verify.log"
      ],
      "observed": "Actual Blender5.2.2LTS reopen/FBX-import logs, named body/equipment/review collections, m Z-up to -Z-forward/Y-up, no animation. Face/ribbon not included in FBX and preserve source atlas SHA."
    }
  ],
  "remaining": [
    "Full hero plus three-landscape presentation and explicit user model approval are still required before any runtime adoption.",
    "One representative hero per group, quantity/ID/collider boundaries and scene selection are later Unity integration checks."
  ]
}