{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "reviewer": "model_conformance independent spec reviewer",
  "base": "58410281e015c6600dc543c4e093fd95c036288c",
  "reviewDateUtc": "2026-10-07T17:03:27.724783+00:00",
  "status": "pass",
  "blockers": [],
  "readOnlyScope": "Repository and worktrees read-only; Python bytes/SHA/FBX parsing and image viewing only; no Blender/Unity/commit/runtime adoption. Writes limited to .dryforge/reviews evidence.",
  "userApproval": "PENDING; this review does not approve runtime adoption",
  "runtimeVerification": "NOT_RUN; later approved Unity integration must verify actual interaction, selection, 30-stage mapping and Android",
  "task": "T2",
  "branch": "dryforge/meadow-model",
  "commit": "80be80566a309eab8cb333ea9774218c816efc30",
  "worktree": "C:\\git\\MagnetismHeroes\\.dryforge\\worktrees\\T2",
  "changedFiles": 25,
  "evidenceRoot": "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow",
  "artifacts": [
    {
      "path": "SourceAssets/Models/Meadow/MeadowCandidates.blend",
      "bytes": 1350505,
      "sha256": "2d95f1797c1a1042e32bb2588d0bde735b6e109a5f947b1f0720c7537bda6ea9"
    },
    {
      "path": "tools/models/build_meadow.py",
      "bytes": 43245,
      "sha256": "f0e7717a5154bf85eeff68639f6f21ca1f79f6d69af8fa0125acf43415f32db1"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/DaisyColony.fbx",
      "bytes": 179196,
      "sha256": "a646a875d99b7cbcef727723b45c6a1e5d6231255ef100689fe69db2e55af63c"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/DistantRidge.fbx",
      "bytes": 67788,
      "sha256": "af68a4b08e0696cb0b56acf92bf0753d288ad6ba89fd4f19b183995f4ed6fd0c"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/FarHorizon.fbx",
      "bytes": 66924,
      "sha256": "fcfb4a768ca33ab9ccd166f7e4b3a96cbc918d1a564f59144b0fab399cb7c179"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/FernCluster.fbx",
      "bytes": 202508,
      "sha256": "9153c91cb71a762c54bc0bc3c5e6fcfe2650185defaf60b5da75e25d78aa4911"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/GentleHill.fbx",
      "bytes": 67420,
      "sha256": "356d3baa0927264f7807e13f3acb717b0c040ae09b23b8feac67e717142d3a19"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/GrassTuftGold.fbx",
      "bytes": 72908,
      "sha256": "0b2a3d68909b56ecdd3324503d3a6bc2b2f9dc8e1d173536dfe52ca96e49521f"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/GrassTuftMint.fbx",
      "bytes": 72700,
      "sha256": "650e02dab0ae3a0f05d036e2d58846cb97a93b77864cbc2c704b4364c26d9962"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/LavenderLupineColony.fbx",
      "bytes": 250284,
      "sha256": "596266e001d7765634ff749deee33cbece1e5bb69ba693bf8c34da795f4f7bdb"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/LowLimestone.fbx",
      "bytes": 47228,
      "sha256": "026abf6db9395751e7ad933455bacc96a06fe331a4bb777001ee29bf33f8417d"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/MeadowClearing.fbx",
      "bytes": 68284,
      "sha256": "78c307844de3ef5584aaa0bec3e57500f9115065dd643686473e52632d551a29"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/MintShrub.fbx",
      "bytes": 96012,
      "sha256": "f501d302845a6df4814076abf76bdd97f5ffd2f0527f2aff236e0b97e78e62da"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/MossStoneSteps.fbx",
      "bytes": 155068,
      "sha256": "5a1bf51f80abde9a9a9e7a419ad30509ad62beac372244e0aba5681896a01739"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/OpenStoneArch.fbx",
      "bytes": 34636,
      "sha256": "8835e7c96ca842ddece1c1f7c9d168a1eabf4f0555e5a025bf46637969dff243"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/PebbleScatter.fbx",
      "bytes": 32060,
      "sha256": "34748a549b40ebe8a53cb57d9638ccbf3e480e8b56453b686c378db8a069da8f"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/PinkCosmosColony.fbx",
      "bytes": 153516,
      "sha256": "6bfc69131ff2cde84f858aa50e3e11697679073d3cd1d0a39a15f4b02cc3afb6"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/RoundCanopyTree.fbx",
      "bytes": 147772,
      "sha256": "9a41dcb9cb40e080bf4be6418f68eb5893561d9454e54a79a402f936ceb59757"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/RoundLimestone.fbx",
      "bytes": 48700,
      "sha256": "eaff76573039ab66927749569e511d5031e90c9ceb7dd8d7cccd84ab7032ca36"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/SageCanopyTree.fbx",
      "bytes": 147772,
      "sha256": "26665d557ef176a9fcce24107d19619b9848552538482eae4b35ebd9fbcd0aec"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/SageShrub.fbx",
      "bytes": 96108,
      "sha256": "fbfed3947cc3e05c82f5660bae9c864576839174c7f72c0cbf0a278d6847eefc"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/SlateBoulder.fbx",
      "bytes": 49852,
      "sha256": "48da619e712ba4ee21c55baea8d93ce656db8a1c30475f0d2cb6bfecfc3b0a84"
    },
    {
      "path": "Assets/MagnetismHeroes/UnityRuntime/Presentation/Models/Meadow/TallWindTree.fbx",
      "bytes": 116140,
      "sha256": "378cdb0fc1d67a980d67d51a469148a6d720a03c9e650b35979bcf98ddf6bcad"
    }
  ],
  "directFbxVerification": [
    {
      "asset": "DaisyColony",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 3225,
      "triangles": 6210,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "Stem",
        "LeafSage",
        "PetalCream",
        "PollenHoney"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "DistantRidge",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1089,
      "triangles": 2174,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "RidgeTeal",
        "RidgeLight",
        "SoilWarm"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "FarHorizon",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1089,
      "triangles": 2174,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "RidgeFar",
        "SoilWarm"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "FernCluster",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 3906,
      "triangles": 7504,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "LeafSage",
        "Stem"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "GentleHill",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1089,
      "triangles": 2174,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "GroundMint",
        "GroundSage",
        "SoilWarm"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "GrassTuftGold",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1026,
      "triangles": 1976,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "GrassGold",
        "GrassMint"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "GrassTuftMint",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1026,
      "triangles": 1976,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "GrassGold",
        "GrassMint"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "LavenderLupineColony",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 4836,
      "triangles": 9304,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "Stem",
        "LeafSage",
        "PetalLavender"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "LowLimestone",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 536,
      "triangles": 1068,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "StoneCream",
        "StoneLight",
        "StoneShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "MeadowClearing",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1089,
      "triangles": 2174,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "GroundMint",
        "GroundSage",
        "SoilWarm"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "MintShrub",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1524,
      "triangles": 2968,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "BarkHoney",
        "LeafMint",
        "LeafLight",
        "LeafShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "MossStoneSteps",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 3267,
      "triangles": 6522,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "StoneCream",
        "StoneLight",
        "StoneShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "OpenStoneArch",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 396,
      "triangles": 788,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "StoneCream",
        "StoneLight",
        "StoneShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "PebbleScatter",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 336,
      "triangles": 656,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "StoneCream",
        "StoneLight"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "PinkCosmosColony",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 2685,
      "triangles": 5170,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "Stem",
        "LeafSage",
        "PetalPink",
        "PollenHoney"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "RoundCanopyTree",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 2486,
      "triangles": 4840,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "BarkHoney",
        "LeafMint",
        "LeafLight",
        "LeafShade",
        "BarkLight"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "RoundLimestone",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 563,
      "triangles": 1122,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "StoneCream",
        "StoneLight",
        "StoneShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "SageCanopyTree",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 2486,
      "triangles": 4840,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "BarkHoney",
        "LeafSage",
        "LeafLight",
        "LeafShade",
        "BarkLight"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "SageShrub",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1524,
      "triangles": 2968,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "BarkHoney",
        "LeafSage",
        "LeafLight",
        "LeafShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "SlateBoulder",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 577,
      "triangles": 1150,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "StoneBlue",
        "StoneLight",
        "StoneShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    },
    {
      "asset": "TallWindTree",
      "fbxVersion": 7400,
      "meshCount": 1,
      "vertices": 1936,
      "triangles": 3804,
      "floorPivot": true,
      "localScaleOne": true,
      "localOriginZero": true,
      "nativeBoundsMatch": true,
      "uvPresent": true,
      "finiteNormals": true,
      "materialSlots": [
        "BarkHoney",
        "PineMint",
        "LeafLight",
        "LeafShade"
      ],
      "animationAbsent": true
    }
  ],
  "hashes": "All 23 resource byte counts/SHA and all10 actual PNG SHA with recorded source SHA independently matched",
  "preservation": "PlaygroundProps.blend plus 13 original FBX byte-identical; diff25 added candidate/tool/doc files only; no manual meta/runtime wiring",
  "findings": [
    {
      "spec": "R01 cyan clear daytime / pastel natural cute cartoon coherent with reference",
      "evidence": [
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Preview_ClearMeadow.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Preview_FlowerHills.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Preview_StoneHills.png",
        "tools/models/build_meadow.py:376"
      ],
      "observed": "Three actual overviews viewed: cyan sky, rounded foliage/ground/horizon, pastel flowers and warm soft daylight. Hero and natural scenery use a coherent rounded cartoon direction; no copied reference character/weapon/UI geometry."
    },
    {
      "spec": "R04 three landscapes; R05 editable detailed nature and unobscured playable center",
      "evidence": [
        "tools/models/build_meadow.py:217",
        "tools/models/build_meadow.py:249",
        "tools/models/build_meadow.py:456",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Closeup_BranchesAndLeaves.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Closeup_PetalsStemsLeaves.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Closeup_OpenArchAndTerraces.png"
      ],
      "observed": "All10 PNGs independently viewed. Meadow, denser pink/cream/lavender flower hills and rock-heavy hills are distinct. Tree branches/root/canopy/leaves, shrub, individual grass/fern blades, flower petals/stems/leaves, rock planes, rolling ground and open arch are present. Central low-density play area remains readable in candidate composition."
    },
    {
      "spec": "R06 native blend +21FBX floor pivots/unit scales/UV/material slots/hash/license and original preservation",
      "evidence": [
        "SourceAssets/Models/Meadow/provenance.json",
        "SourceAssets/Models/Meadow/README.md",
        "tools/models/build_meadow.py:550",
        "tools/models/build_meadow.py:582",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/source-verification.json",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/verify-only.log",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/run-evidence.json"
      ],
      "observed": "Source reopened and 21 actual FBX roundtrips are recorded with exit0. Independent FBX byte parsing verified single mesh per file, exact vertex/triangle counts and native bounds, floor minZ0, default scale1/origin0, UV and finite normals, exact named material slots, axis rotation and no animation. All23 source/tool/export records matched SHA/bytes."
    },
    {
      "spec": "R07 no unintentional dark patches/checker faceting/ground seams harming readability/coherence",
      "evidence": [
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Preview_ClearMeadow.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Preview_FlowerHills.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Preview_StoneHills.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Catalog_RockPlanes.png",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/Closeup_BranchesAndLeaves.png"
      ],
      "observed": "No unintended black patch/checkerboard or open ground gap across assembled center. Broad intentional rock planes and ordinary foliage/ground shadows are not classified as violations."
    },
    {
      "spec": "R10 candidate review output and no adoption before explicit user approval",
      "evidence": [
        "SourceAssets/Models/Meadow/README.md",
        "SourceAssets/Models/Meadow/provenance.json",
        "artifacts/verification/VisualUpgrade/ModelReview/Meadow/render-manifest.json"
      ],
      "observed": "Three overview, four catalog and three detail renders, editable source and exact SHA are available. Metadata marks approval/import/gameplay/mobile PENDING or NOT_RUN. No runtime refs or meta added."
    }
  ],
  "remaining": [
    "Explicit user approval of hero plus all three landscape candidates before any actual-game reference replacement/runtime adoption.",
    "30-stage runtime mapping, actual sphere-position preservation, near-prop collider/arch selection, camera/zoom readability and Android performance require later approved integration."
  ]
}